Share This

Percentages are easy to accept on a quote and hard to feel until a storm arrives. On a high-value home, a hurricane deductible is not a few thousand dollars. It can be a six-figure decision. This article works through the numbers on a $3 million home so you can choose a deductible deliberately. For the fundamentals of how Florida hurricane deductibles work, start with our guide to understanding hurricane deductibles.

The Starting Point: Percentages of the Dwelling Limit

Most Florida hurricane deductibles are a percentage of the dwelling limit (Coverage A), not a percentage of the damage. On a home insured for $3,000,000:

  • 2% deductible: $60,000
  • 5% deductible: $150,000
  • 10% deductible: $300,000

The deductible is based on the dwelling limit even when the damage is mostly to contents, the pool enclosure, or landscaping. That is why it is often much larger than homeowners expect.

Example One: A Moderate Hurricane

Suppose a hurricane damages the roof, several impact windows, and interior finishes, and the covered loss totals $220,000.

  • With a 2% deductible, the policy pays $160,000 and you pay $60,000.
  • With a 5% deductible, the policy pays $70,000 and you pay $150,000.
  • With a 10% deductible, the policy pays nothing, because the loss is below the $300,000 deductible.

Moderate storms like this are far more common than catastrophic ones, so the deductible often determines whether a claim is worth filing at all.

Example Two: A Major Hurricane

Now suppose a major hurricane causes a $1.2 million covered loss. The policy pays $1,140,000 with a 2% deductible, $1,050,000 with 5%, and $900,000 with 10%. In a large loss, the deductible is a smaller share of the total, and other features, such as extended replacement cost and additional living expenses, matter more. Our article on guaranteed and extended replacement cost explains why.

Example Three: Two Storms in One Season

Florida law requires hurricane deductibles on admitted personal lines residential policies to apply once per calendar year. If a first hurricane causes $40,000 of damage on a home with a $60,000 deductible, you absorb the $40,000. If a second hurricane strikes later that year, the deductible for the second storm is the greater of the remaining $20,000 or your regular all-other-perils deductible. Keep receipts and records of smaller hurricane losses, because they can count toward a later claim. Surplus lines policies may handle multiple storms differently, so confirm the terms.

Weighing Premium Savings Against Retained Risk

A higher deductible lowers the premium, and the question is whether the savings justify the risk you keep. Consider a hypothetical: moving from a 2% to a 5% deductible saves $9,000 a year. You take on an additional $90,000 of exposure per hurricane season. At that rate, it would take ten years of savings to offset one moderate storm. Actual savings vary widely by carrier, location, and construction, so we calculate this trade-off with real quotes for every client.

Questions that help frame the decision:

  • Could you comfortably pay the deductible in cash after a storm, alongside temporary housing and mitigation costs?
  • How strong is the home’s wind resistance? A well-mitigated home may justify a higher deductible.
  • Is the home your primary residence or a seasonal property you may not be able to inspect quickly?
  • Would you rather self-insure smaller storms and rely on insurance for catastrophic losses?

Do Not Forget Flood

Storm surge and rising water are excluded from homeowners and wind policies. Flood is insured separately, with its own deductible. A storm that floods a coastal home can trigger both a hurricane deductible and a flood deductible. Our article on flood insurance for high-value homes covers primary and excess flood options.

A Decision Worth Revisiting Every Year

Your ideal deductible changes as your home, finances, and the market change. A new roof or impact windows may make a different deductible more attractive, and some carriers offer options that are not available elsewhere. At Eton Bridge Insurance, we model these scenarios with you at each renewal so the deductible you carry is a decision, not a default. Learn more about our high-value home insurance.

If you would like a second opinion on your coverage, call us at 407-351-3331 or request a private client review. Your advisor will walk through your policies with you, explain the options in plain language, and handle the details.

Sources

Modern elevated coastal home on pilings behind sand dunes on a Florida barrier islandNon-Admitted Carriers for Coastal Homes, Explained
Post

The next step is easy, call us at 407-351-3331, or click below to start your insurance quote